Best First Car: A Safe Midsize Sedan
A safe midsize sedan is a solid first car with strong crash-test results and room for passengers.
Your answers point to a safe midsize sedan. A midsize sedan gives a stable, predictable ride and often earns good crash-test ratings. It is large enough to protect its occupants well, common enough that parts and insurance are affordable and calm enough to be a forgiving car to learn on.
Why you landed here
This result tends to come from putting safety and a predictable car first, with a budget that can stretch to a midsize vehicle. It fits families who want a straightforward car without a lot of extras and who care more about how well it protects than how it looks.
Why a midsize sedan suits a new driver
The IIHS reports that bigger, heavier vehicles are safer, and a midsize sedan is large enough to meet that guidance without the higher center of gravity of a tall vehicle. Its handling is generally easy and its braking and cornering are predictable. Choose the standard engine over a sport or high-performance version, because the IIHS advises new drivers to stay away from high horsepower.
Ratings and stability control
Check the IIHS and NHTSA ratings for the exact model and year, because they change between generations. Insist on electronic stability control, which has been required on new vehicles since the 2012 model year, so a used sedan from 2012 or later should have it. Look up open recalls using the VIN before you buy.
Prefer common models
Common sedans have cheap parts, many qualified mechanics and reasonable insurance costs. Rare or high-performance models are harder and costlier to repair and can cost much more to insure, especially with a teen driver. Get insurance quotes for the exact car before you commit.
Buying used or new
A used midsize sedan is a common first-car choice, and it should come with a documented service history, a vehicle history report and an independent mechanic's inspection. A new one costs more and loses value faster, but brings a full warranty and the latest safety systems. The New or Used Car Quiz can help. Run the payment and the total cost with the Car Payment Calculator and the Cost to Own a Car Calculator.
Check the numbers
Other possible results
This quiz gives a general starting point based on your answers. It is not financial, legal or safety advice. Please read our disclaimer and how we calculate.
Frequently asked questions
Is a sedan safer than an SUV?
Not automatically. The IIHS says bigger and heavier is safer, and a midsize sedan meets that guidance. A small SUV weighs about the same as a midsize car, so check the exact model's ratings.
What about used cars from before 2012?
Electronic stability control was not required on all vehicles until the 2012 model year. The IIHS considers it a must, so check for it on any older car.
Should the engine be powerful?
No. The IIHS advises new drivers to avoid high-horsepower versions. A standard engine is enough and usually costs less to insure.
All DriverCalcs tools
Fuel & Mileage
MPG Calculator Fuel Cost Calculator Road Trip Cost Calculator Cost Per Mile Calculator Commute Cost Calculator Mileage Reimbursement Calculator EV Charging Cost Calculator Electric vs Hybrid vs Gas CalculatorBuying & Loans
Car Affordability Calculator Car Payment Calculator Car Loan Payoff Calculator Lease vs Buy Calculator Car Sales Tax CalculatorOwnership Costs
Car Depreciation Calculator Cost to Own a Car Calculator Car Registration Fee CalculatorNo calculators match your search.