Best First Car: A Small SUV

A small SUV or crossover suits new drivers who need space or drive in poor weather.

Your answers point to a small SUV. A small crossover offers good visibility, flexible cargo space and optional all-wheel drive. It costs a little more to buy and fuel than a compact car, and it suits families who need room for friends and gear or who face bad weather.

Why you landed here

This result tends to come from a need for space, a driver who faces rain, snow or rough roads and a budget that can handle a higher price and slightly higher running costs. It is a practical choice when a car is also expected to carry sports gear or a few passengers.

Why a small SUV can be a reasonable choice

The IIHS advises bigger and heavier vehicles for new drivers and leaves minicars and small cars off its lists. It does include small SUVs, because they weigh about the same as a midsize car. The seating position also gives a good view of traffic. As with any choice, check the exact model's crash-test ratings, since they differ a lot between models.

All-wheel drive is not a substitute for care

All-wheel drive can help a car get going on a slippery road, but it does not help it stop or turn any better than a front-wheel-drive car with the same tires. Good tires, and winter tires where roads are icy, make more difference to braking and cornering. Talk to your teen about slowing down in bad weather, whatever the vehicle.

Stability control and tall vehicles

A taller vehicle has a higher center of gravity, and electronic stability control helps a driver keep control on curves and slippery roads. It has been required on new vehicles since the 2012 model year. Make sure any used SUV has it, and avoid high-horsepower versions, which the IIHS advises against for new drivers.

Costs to expect

A small SUV usually uses more fuel than a compact car, and its tires are often more expensive. Insurance varies by model, so get quotes. Use the Cost to Own a Car Calculator to compare it with a sedan, the Fuel Cost Calculator for the yearly fuel bill and the Tire Size Calculator if you plan to change wheels or tires.

Check the numbers

Retake the quiz

Other possible results

This quiz gives a general starting point based on your answers. It is not financial, legal or safety advice. Please read our disclaimer and how we calculate.

Frequently asked questions

Is all-wheel drive necessary for a teen?

Not usually. It helps with traction when accelerating on slippery roads, but good tires and careful driving matter more for stopping and turning.

Are SUVs more likely to roll over?

Taller vehicles have a higher center of gravity, but electronic stability control, required on new vehicles since the 2012 model year, reduces the risk. Check the model's ratings.

Do SUVs cost more to insure?

It varies by model. Compare quotes for the specific vehicles you are considering.

All DriverCalcs tools